In the world of mutual funds, trust is currency. Investors agree to hand over their money on the belief that Asset Management Companies (AMCs) will handle it responsibly. Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs), in particular, are sold as transparent, flexible, and investor-friendly — you can start them anytime and stop them anytime.
But what happens when “stop” doesn’t mean stop?
In recent years, numerous investors have reported a disturbing practice: some AMCs continued to auto-debit SIP contributions even after investors had canceled their plans. The incidents may look like clerical errors on the surface, but the repetition across cases suggests something more systemic — a mix of profit incentives, weak controls, and inadequate regulation.
This article investigates how such auto-debits happen, why they persist, who benefits, and what this reveals about the darker underbelly of the SIP industry.
How SIP Auto-Debits Work
The Standard Flow
- Investors authorize banks/UPI systems for periodic debits.
- AMCs and payment processors use this mandate to collect SIP installments.
- Cancellation requests are supposed to revoke mandates.
The Gap
- Cancellations must be processed by both the AMC and the bank.
- If one party fails or delays, debits continue.
- Investors assume their instructions were final but later see money deducted.
The Scandal: When Cancellation Fails
Reports show a recurring pattern:
- Investors request SIP cancellation — via AMC website, distributor, or bank.
- They receive acknowledgments, believing the SIP is terminated.
- Despite this, installments continue to be debited for weeks or even months.
- Refunds, if any, are delayed and require repeated follow-ups.
For investors, this isn’t just a nuisance. It’s a breach of trust — the very foundation on which the mutual fund industry rests.
Why It Happens
1. AMC Revenue Incentives
- Each extra installment adds to Assets Under Management (AUM).
- More AUM means more fee income through expense ratios.
- Delayed cancellations create a perverse incentive for AMCs not to prioritize investor instructions.
2. Distributor Pressure
- Distributors and bank relationship managers earn trail commissions as long as SIPs remain active.
- They may “forget” to process cancellation requests quickly.
3. Systemic Loopholes
- Multiple intermediaries (AMC, registrar, bank, payment gateway) must coordinate.
- Any delay in revoking mandates keeps debits alive.
4. Blame Game
- AMCs blame banks, banks blame AMCs, and investors are left in the middle.
Case Studies
Case 1: The Young Professional
A Bengaluru software engineer canceled her SIP online in 2021. Despite email confirmation, her account was debited for two more months. When she complained, the AMC claimed “bank delay,” while the bank insisted the AMC hadn’t revoked the mandate.
Case 2: The Retired Couple
In Mumbai, a retired couple canceled their SIPs due to medical expenses. But debits continued for three months, totaling nearly ₹60,000. They struggled for refunds, facing endless back-and-forth between the AMC and bank.
Case 3: The Mass Complaint Forum
On several investor forums, threads reveal dozens of cases where SIP cancellations were acknowledged but debits continued. The pattern suggests systemic negligence rather than isolated incidents.
The Human Impact
- Financial Stress
Retirees and salaried professionals budget carefully. Unwanted debits disrupt household cash flows. - Loss of Trust
Investors feel betrayed by institutions they considered safe. - Opportunity Cost
Money wrongfully deducted cannot be used for urgent needs. - Psychological Anguish
Chasing refunds across bureaucratic silos is exhausting for ordinary investors.
Who Benefits?
- AMCs: Even temporary AUM boosts allow them to collect more management fees.
- Distributors: SIPs remain “active,” ensuring commissions continue.
- Banks: Debit transactions generate processing revenues.
For investors, there is no benefit — only cost.
Regulatory Loopholes
1. Lack of Standardized Cancellation Protocol
Different AMCs follow different processes, confusing investors.
2. Weak Accountability
No clear rule defines whether the AMC, registrar, or bank is liable for wrongful debits.
3. Token Disclaimers
AMC websites state: “Cancellations may take 30 days to process.” Investors rarely notice this clause.
4. Inadequate Penalties
Even when wrongful debits are proven, AMCs face little more than reputational risk.
Why This Isn’t Just a “Clerical Error”
The pattern suggests something deeper:
- Repeated across multiple AMCs.
- Always benefits the AMC/distributor, never the investor.
- Resolution requires disproportionate effort by investors.
- Refunds often exclude opportunity costs or interest.
This points less to random error and more to systemic indifference enabled by incentives.
Global Parallels
- UK PPI Scandal: Banks continued to charge premiums for unwanted insurance policies.
- U.S. Subscription Economy: Companies design cancellation processes to be deliberately cumbersome.
- Asian ULIP Mis-Selling: Customers thought they canceled, but hidden clauses kept charges alive.
The auto-debit SIP issue fits this global pattern of exploiting inertia and weak oversight.
Warning Signs for Investors
- AMC disclaimers about “30–45 days for cancellation.”
- Lack of acknowledgment receipts from banks.
- SIPs started via distributors, where paperwork may not be fully updated.
- Delayed stop instructions given near debit dates.
What Regulators Should Do
- Mandate Real-Time Cancellations
Digital cancellations must trigger immediate revocation of bank mandates. - Define Liability
If debits continue post-cancellation, AMCs should refund with interest. - Audit Trails
Investors should be able to track cancellation status across AMC, bank, and registrar systems. - Penalties for Repeat Offenders
AMCs with recurring cases should face fines or suspension of sales. - Investor Compensation
Wrongful debits should be refunded with penalty interest, not just principal.
How Investors Can Protect Themselves
- Cancel at Both Ends
Always revoke SIPs both at AMC and bank (via standing instruction or UPI mandate). - Document Everything
Keep cancellation receipts, emails, and screenshots. - Monitor Accounts Closely
Track debits for 2–3 months post-cancellation. - Escalate Quickly
If refunds are delayed, escalate to SEBI’s SCORES portal or banking ombudsman. - Avoid Distributor Dependence
Initiate and cancel SIPs directly via AMC or trusted digital platforms.
Could This Erupt Into a Major Scandal?
Yes. If widespread, the practice could trigger a public backlash similar to past financial mis-selling crises. If thousands of investors realize they were debited post-cancellation, lawsuits and regulatory crackdowns could follow.
The reputational risk to AMCs is enormous: SIPs are built on the idea of transparency and flexibility. If “cancel” doesn’t mean cancel, the entire narrative collapses.
Conclusion
SIPs are sold as the simplest, safest way to invest: you can start anytime, stop anytime. But the reality of AMCs auto-debiting after cancellations undermines this promise. Whether through negligence, systemic loopholes, or deliberate profit motives, the result is the same: investors lose money, while AMCs, distributors, and banks benefit.
The scandal is not just about wrongful debits — it’s about trust betrayed. For the SIP ecosystem to retain credibility, regulators must enforce strict accountability, and investors must remain vigilant.
Until then, the uncomfortable truth remains: in the AMC world, sometimes “stop” doesn’t really mean stop.
ALSO READ: Metaverse token overvaluation
