On Tuesday, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) announced a series of significant changes to the index derivatives trading framework. This move aims to address growing concerns about excessive speculation and mounting losses incurred by retail traders. The updated rules include measures to increase contract sizes, tighten margin requirements, limit weekly expiries, and impose stricter monitoring protocols. With these changes, SEBI hopes to create a safer and more stable trading environment, particularly for retail investors.
The Context: Why SEBI Stepped In
The decision to overhaul the index derivatives trading framework did not come out of the blue. Over the past three financial years, a staggering 93% of retail traders have suffered losses in the futures and options (F&O) segment, with total losses amounting to Rs 1.8 trillion. This worrying trend has led to concerns among financial regulators and stakeholders, including the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and the Chief Economic Advisor.
The growing popularity of F&O trading, especially among individual traders, has contributed to an enormous rise in average daily turnover, which now exceeds Rs 500 trillion. The high volume and hyperactivity in this segment have triggered calls for reforms to ensure investor protection and market stability.
SEBI’s recent study highlighted the need for stronger regulations to protect retail investors from incurring large, often irreversible, losses. In response, SEBI issued a consultation paper in July, which outlined several proposals aimed at curbing excessive speculation. The proposals were reviewed by an expert working group and the secondary market advisory committee, culminating in the new measures announced this week.
Key Changes to the Index Derivatives Framework
SEBI’s new rules represent a multi-faceted approach to reducing risk and speculation in the derivatives market. The six key changes are:
- Increasing the Contract Size from Rs 5 Lakh to Rs 15 Lakh
The minimum contract size for index derivatives has been raised from Rs 5 lakh to Rs 15 lakh. This means that, at the time of introduction, the value of a derivative contract cannot be lower than Rs 15 lakh. This is the first revision in contract size in nine years. The increase is intended to raise the entry barrier for retail participants, making it more challenging for small traders to take oversized positions. Going forward, the lot size will be set so that the contract value remains between Rs 15 lakh and Rs 20 lakh. - Raising Margin Requirements
SEBI has introduced stricter margin requirements, which will apply to all index derivative contracts. Additionally, there will be an extreme loss margin (ELM) of 2% for short options contracts. This new ELM rule will apply to all open short options positions at the start of the day, as well as short options contracts initiated during the day and due for expiry on the same day. This change aims to deter speculative trading strategies that expose traders to excessive risk. - Mandating Upfront Collection of Option Premiums
Brokers will now be required to collect option premiums upfront from buyers. This will prevent traders from leveraging their positions intraday without sufficient collateral. This measure will also discourage practices that involve traders taking on positions exceeding their available capital, which has been a common issue in the F&O segment. - Limiting Weekly Expiries to One Benchmark Per Exchange
One of the most significant changes is the limitation of weekly expiries to just one benchmark index per exchange. The NSE is expected to retain weekly expiries for Nifty, while the BSE will hold weekly expiries for Sensex. This change removes the current practice of multiple expiries, which can lead to hyperactive trading, especially on expiry days. SEBI believes this step will help mitigate risks to investor protection and market stability without hampering capital formation. - Intraday Monitoring of Position Limits
SEBI has mandated that stock exchanges monitor position limits for equity index derivatives on an intraday basis. The new rule, set to be effective from April 2025, is designed to prevent large traders from manipulating the market. It will ensure that no single trader or group of traders can take undue advantage of their positions to influence market movements. - Removal of Calendar Spread Treatment on Expiry Days
The removal of calendar spread treatment on expiry days means that traders will no longer benefit from the lower margin requirements that typically apply to positions involving different expiration dates. This move is aimed at ensuring that all positions, regardless of their expiration date, are treated uniformly in terms of risk management on expiry days.
The Expected Impact of These Changes
SEBI’s new measures are expected to have a broad impact on the derivatives market, particularly for retail traders. The changes will make it more difficult for small traders to enter the market with highly leveraged positions, thus reducing the likelihood of significant losses.
Raising the Contract Size: The decision to increase the contract size is expected to significantly alter the market dynamics. While it will reduce the number of smaller traders, it will also ensure that only those with adequate capital participate in the derivatives market. This should help reduce the overall speculative trading volume and contribute to market stability.
Higher Margins and Upfront Premiums: The increase in margin requirements and the mandatory upfront collection of option premiums will further tighten the rules around leverage. Retail traders will have to maintain higher collateral to participate in the market, which will discourage reckless trading strategies.
Limiting Weekly Expiries: The restriction on weekly expiries is a crucial step. By limiting weekly expiries to one benchmark index per exchange, SEBI aims to reduce the intense trading activity that often occurs on expiry days. This measure is expected to smoothen the volatility spikes typically seen during these periods, leading to a more stable trading environment.
Intraday Monitoring of Position Limits: The introduction of intraday monitoring of position limits will help detect and prevent manipulative trading practices in real-time. This measure will provide an additional layer of security, ensuring that no trader or group of traders can dominate the market unduly.
Short-Term and Long-Term Implications
In the short term, SEBI’s new rules are likely to reduce trading volumes, especially among retail participants. The immediate impact may include a decline in the number of active traders in the F&O segment, as those with limited capital may find it difficult to meet the new requirements.
In the long term, however, these measures are expected to create a healthier market environment. By raising entry barriers and imposing stricter rules, SEBI aims to protect retail investors from excessive losses. The changes will likely attract more serious and well-capitalized investors, contributing to a more stable and less speculative market.
The reforms may also lead to a shift in trading strategies. With the removal of calendar spread treatment and the imposition of additional margins on short options contracts, traders may need to adopt more conservative strategies. This could lead to a decline in speculative trades and an increase in hedging or long-term investment strategies.
The Road Ahead: What’s Next for SEBI?
SEBI has indicated that these changes are just the beginning. While the current measures focus on raising entry barriers and reducing speculation, additional steps to curb excessive trading activity may be in the pipeline. SEBI has previously revised the eligibility criteria for stock selection in the F&O segment, and further modifications could be on the horizon.
The regulator is likely to continue monitoring the impact of these changes closely. If the new rules lead to a significant reduction in retail trader losses, SEBI may consider extending similar reforms to other segments of the market. On the other hand, if the measures fail to achieve the desired outcomes, SEBI may explore alternative approaches to strengthen market integrity and investor protection.
Conclusion
SEBI’s decision to revamp the index derivatives trading framework is a bold step towards creating a safer and more regulated market environment. By increasing the contract size, raising margin requirements, limiting weekly expiries, and implementing stricter monitoring, SEBI aims to curb excessive speculation and protect retail traders from sustaining significant losses.
While these changes will likely reduce trading volumes and impact small traders in the short term, they are expected to lead to a healthier and more stable market in the long run. SEBI’s proactive approach reflects its commitment to investor protection and market stability, and its willingness to adapt its regulations as needed to address emerging challenges.
For traders and investors, the message is clear: SEBI’s new rules demand greater responsibility and discipline. As the markets evolve under this new regulatory framework, traders will need to adapt their strategies and embrace a more cautious approach to trading. Only time will tell whether these measures will be enough to curb excessive speculation and create a more resilient market, but for now, SEBI has made its intentions clear: protecting retail investors and ensuring the long-term stability of India’s capital markets.
ALSO READ: Stock Market Faces Pressure Amid Rising Middle East Tensions
