Adoption of Crypto for Remittances Falters in El Salvador
El Salvador made history in 2021 by becoming the first country to adopt Bitcoin (BTC) as legal tender, a move that sparked global debate about the role of cryptocurrencies in national economies. A key selling point of this decision was crypto-based remittances, which the government claimed would help citizens save on high transaction fees charged by traditional financial institutions. However, despite the initial enthusiasm, crypto remittances have failed to gain traction in El Salvador. Instead, the majority of Salvadorans continue to rely on conventional remittance services, signaling that Bitcoin has yet to displace traditional financial infrastructure.
Decline in Crypto Remittance Adoption
John Paul Koning, a prominent financial analyst, recently highlighted via social media that the use of crypto for remittances has significantly declined since its peak in October 2021. Initially, Bitcoin-based transfers accounted for nearly 5% of total remittances into the country. However, by December 2024, this number had fallen below 1%, suggesting a significant retreat from Bitcoin-based transactions for cross-border payments.
This decline raises several questions about the effectiveness of cryptocurrency in addressing the remittance needs of Salvadorans. It also suggests that the government’s ambitious plan to use Bitcoin to disrupt the remittance industry has not materialized as expected.
Why Were Crypto Remittances Promoted?
El Salvador’s government, led by President Nayib Bukele, framed Bitcoin adoption as a means to help citizens save money on remittance fees. According to Bukele, traditional remittance services, such as Western Union and MoneyGram, were taking up to 25% in fees, collectively costing Salvadorans living abroad nearly $400 million annually in lost funds.
Bukele’s administration promoted the Chivo Wallet, a government-backed digital wallet, as a zero-commission alternative that would enable instant, cost-free transactions using Bitcoin. To encourage adoption, the government even airdropped $30 worth of Bitcoin to every citizen who registered with the app.
However, despite these incentives, the transition to Bitcoin-based remittances did not happen at the scale anticipated by the government. Instead, Salvadorans have largely continued to rely on traditional remittance providers.
Challenges Facing Crypto Remittances in El Salvador
Several factors have contributed to the decline in Bitcoin remittance adoption in the country:
1. Volatility of Bitcoin
Bitcoin’s price fluctuations remain one of the biggest challenges to its widespread use as a remittance tool. Unlike stable fiat currencies such as the U.S. dollar, Bitcoin’s value can fluctuate dramatically within hours, leading to potential losses for both senders and recipients. This uncertainty makes traditional remittance services a more reliable and predictable option for Salvadorans who depend on stable cash flow from abroad.
2. Limited Trust and Understanding
Many Salvadorans remain skeptical about Bitcoin and digital wallets. While some tech-savvy individuals have embraced cryptocurrency, a significant portion of the population lacks the technical knowledge or confidence to use digital wallets for financial transactions. This hesitation has contributed to the continued reliance on cash-based traditional remittance services.
3. Chivo Wallet’s Operational Issues
The Chivo Wallet, envisioned as a game-changer for Bitcoin adoption, has faced multiple technical and operational challenges, including:
- Glitches and downtime preventing transactions from processing smoothly.
- Lack of customer support to resolve user issues.
- Instances of identity fraud where unauthorized individuals gained access to other people’s airdrop funds.
These issues led many Salvadorans to abandon the Chivo Wallet, undermining Bitcoin’s role as a remittance solution.
4. Government’s Policy Reversal
Under an agreement with the International Monetary Fund (IMF), El Salvador has agreed to scale back its Bitcoin integration in the economy. As part of this agreement:
- The legal tender status of Bitcoin in the country will be terminated.
- The Chivo Wallet’s operations will be shut down or sold.
This shift further discourages Bitcoin adoption in El Salvador and signals that the government may be moving away from its pro-crypto stance.
Traditional Remittance Services Maintain Dominance
Despite Bitcoin’s promise of lower fees, Salvadorans continue to favor traditional remittance services such as:
- Western Union
- MoneyGram
- Bank Transfers
These platforms offer:
- More stability compared to Bitcoin’s price volatility.
- Widespread accessibility, with physical locations for cash pickups.
- Familiarity, as Salvadorans have relied on them for decades.
Implications for Bitcoin Adoption in Other Countries
El Salvador’s struggle with crypto remittances provides key lessons for other nations considering cryptocurrency integration:
- Crypto adoption must align with user behavior – Simply introducing Bitcoin does not guarantee adoption; education and infrastructure improvements are crucial.
- Stablecoins may be a better alternative – Unlike Bitcoin, stablecoins such as USDC and USDT do not experience extreme volatility, making them more practical for remittances.
- Trust in technology is essential – If users lack trust in digital wallets or experience issues, they will revert to familiar services.
What’s Next for Crypto in El Salvador?
With Bitcoin losing its legal tender status and the government scaling back crypto initiatives, the future of Bitcoin in El Salvador remains uncertain. However, the government still holds a reserve of Bitcoin assets, and Bukele has expressed a commitment to long-term Bitcoin adoption.
Potential future developments include:
- Integration of Stablecoins for Remittances: If Bitcoin’s volatility is a barrier, the government might consider stablecoin-based solutions.
- Regulatory Adjustments: With the IMF’s involvement, the government could introduce new regulations to balance innovation with economic stability.
- Development of Private Crypto Services: With Chivo Wallet’s phase-out, private fintech firms might step in to fill the gap left by the government.
Conclusion
El Salvador’s experience with Bitcoin-based remittances highlights the challenges of integrating crypto into an existing financial ecosystem. While the promise of lower fees and financial inclusion was compelling, practical issues such as price volatility, limited adoption, and technical failures have led to a decline in Bitcoin remittances.
Despite setbacks, El Salvador remains a key case study for national cryptocurrency adoption, and its evolving crypto policies will continue to shape the future of Bitcoin’s role in global finance.
ALSO READ: US Crypto Regulations Evolve: Will Adoption Follow?
