The Luckin Coffee accounting fraud

In the late 2010s, Luckin Coffee emerged as China’s answer to Starbucks, growing at an astonishing pace and attracting billions in investment. Founded in 2017, it positioned itself as a disruptive startup, using aggressive promotions, mobile-first ordering, and deep discounts to build a massive customer base.

By 2019, just two years after its founding, Luckin Coffee was listed on the Nasdaq, raising over $650 million and achieving a valuation above $12 billion. Investors around the world saw it as one of the most promising Chinese startups of the decade.

But the company’s rise was too good to be true. In 2020, Luckin admitted to fabricating over $300 million in sales, triggering one of the largest accounting scandals in Chinese corporate history. The fallout wiped out billions in shareholder value, damaged confidence in Chinese firms, and highlighted the risks of unchecked growth fueled by aggressive reporting.

Background: The Rise of Luckin Coffee

Luckin Coffee was founded in Beijing in October 2017 by Jenny Qian Zhiya, a former COO of car rental giant UCAR, and Lu Zhengyao, UCAR’s chairman.

The company’s model was simple but highly aggressive:

• Rapid Expansion – Within two years, Luckin had opened over 4,500 stores, surpassing Starbucks’ footprint in China.

• Technology Focus – Customers ordered exclusively through Luckin’s app, integrating promotions, discounts, and cashless payments.

• Aggressive Promotions – Luckin offered free drinks, buy-one-get-one deals, and heavy discounts to quickly capture market share.

This strategy resulted in staggering reported growth. By 2019, Luckin was celebrated as a tech-driven unicorn, often touted as “the Starbucks killer” in China.

Nasdaq Listing and Global Hype

In May 2019, Luckin Coffee went public on the Nasdaq, raising $561 million in its IPO. The listing was one of the largest ever for a Chinese company in the U.S.

Highlights from its IPO journey included:

• Opening stock price at $17 per share, quickly climbing to over $50.

• Market capitalization soaring beyond $12 billion.

• Investor enthusiasm driven by the narrative of a fast-scaling disruptor in China’s booming consumer market.

Luckin’s financial reports showed triple-digit revenue growth, positioning it as one of the fastest-growing companies globally. But in reality, much of this revenue was fake.

How the Fraud Worked

Luckin Coffee’s fraud centered around inflated sales figures, achieved through fabricated transactions and manipulated expenses.

1. Fake Sales Transactions

From the second quarter of 2019 through the fourth quarter of 2019, Luckin reported hundreds of millions of dollars in sales that never existed. Employees created fake orders to inflate revenue, disguising them as legitimate customer transactions.

2. Misreported Expenses

To make the fake sales appear authentic, Luckin also inflated expenses such as advertising and discounts, making it seem as though heavy promotional campaigns were driving customer purchases.

3. Involvement of Senior Executives

The fraud was orchestrated at the highest levels, with Chief Operating Officer Jian Liu and other senior employees implicated. Their goal was to maintain the narrative of rapid growth, keep investor money flowing, and support the company’s soaring valuation.

By the time the fraud was revealed, Luckin had fabricated approximately $310 million in sales, equivalent to about 40% of its 2019 revenue.

Discovery of the Fraud

In January 2020, activist short-seller Muddy Waters Research released a report based on independent investigations, alleging that Luckin had inflated its sales figures. The report, citing over 11,000 hours of store traffic monitoring and thousands of customer receipts, concluded that Luckin’s numbers were fraudulent.

Initially, Luckin denied the allegations. But by April 2020, the company admitted that its COO Jian Liu and other employees had fabricated transactions.

This admission confirmed the fraud and triggered a global scandal.

Fallout from the Scandal

The consequences for Luckin Coffee and its stakeholders were severe and immediate:

1. Stock Market Collapse

• Luckin’s shares plummeted more than 80% in a matter of days after the admission.

• The Nasdaq eventually delisted Luckin Coffee in June 2020.

2. Investor Losses

Global investors, including major funds, lost billions as Luckin’s market capitalization collapsed from over $12 billion to less than $1 billion.

3. Executive Ouster

CEO Jenny Qian and COO Jian Liu were fired, alongside dozens of employees involved in the fraud.

4. Legal and Regulatory Action

• In December 2020, Luckin agreed to pay $180 million to settle SEC charges for defrauding investors.

• Chinese regulators also fined the company and imposed penalties on executives.

Impact on Chinese Companies and U.S. Listings

The Luckin scandal had ripple effects beyond the company itself. It intensified scrutiny of Chinese firms listed on U.S. exchanges.

1. Regulatory Pressure – U.S. lawmakers called for stricter oversight of foreign companies, particularly those from China. This led to the Holding Foreign Companies Accountable Act (HFCAA) in 2020, which requires foreign firms listed in the U.S. to comply with U.S. auditing standards.

2. Investor Caution – Global investors became more skeptical of Chinese startups, especially those promising rapid growth.

3. Reputation Damage – The scandal reinforced perceptions of weak corporate governance and lack of transparency in Chinese firms.

Rebuilding Efforts: Luckin’s Survival

Despite predictions of collapse, Luckin Coffee managed to survive. After restructuring and ousting its fraudulent leadership, the company embarked on a turnaround strategy:

• Debt Restructuring – Luckin filed for Chapter 15 bankruptcy protection in the U.S. in 2021 to manage liabilities tied to its fraud.

• New Leadership – A new management team focused on restoring credibility, cutting costs, and improving operations.

• Return to Growth – By 2022–2023, Luckin began reporting genuine profitability and growth, driven by new products and loyal customers in China.

• Stock Revival – Relisted on the over-the-counter market, Luckin’s stock gradually recovered, and by 2023 its market value exceeded $4 billion again.

The company’s resilience surprised many, making it a rare case of a fraudulent firm managing to rebuild after a scandal of this magnitude.

Comparison with Other Corporate Scandals

The Luckin fraud shares similarities with other scandals:

• Enron (2001): Like Enron, Luckin fabricated revenues to maintain growth illusions.

• WorldCom (2002): Both inflated earnings through accounting manipulations.

• Wirecard (2020): Both were global accounting frauds exposed around the same time, shaking investor trust.

What makes Luckin unique is that it was a young startup, not an established conglomerate, and it managed to stage a comeback post-scandal.

Lessons from the Luckin Coffee Fraud

1. Growth Hype Can Blind Investors
   The “Starbucks of China” narrative convinced investors to overlook red flags in pursuit of growth.

2. Corporate Governance is Critical
   Weak internal controls allowed senior executives to manipulate numbers unchecked.

3. Role of Short-Sellers
   The Muddy Waters report highlighted how independent short-sellers can play a vital role in uncovering fraud.

4. Investor Due Diligence
   Global investors must be cautious when investing in high-growth foreign firms, especially those with limited transparency.

5. Reputation Takes Years to Rebuild
   Even after restructuring, Luckin still faces skepticism, proving that once trust is broken, recovery is difficult.

Conclusion

The Luckin Coffee accounting fraud was one of the largest corporate scandals in Chinese history, involving $310 million in fabricated sales and wiping out billions in shareholder wealth. It exposed systemic weaknesses in corporate governance, highlighted the risks of unchecked growth narratives, and triggered regulatory reforms affecting all foreign firms listed in the U.S.

Yet, unlike Enron or WorldCom, Luckin managed to survive. Through restructuring, new leadership, and genuine growth, it clawed its way back into profitability, though its reputation remains scarred.

For investors, regulators, and businesses alike, the Luckin scandal is a stark reminder: in the pursuit of growth and market dominance, integrity cannot be sacrificed. Otherwise, even the most promising companies risk collapse under the weight of their own deception.

ALSO READ: The hidden hand of investment banks in shaping U.S. elections