Retail investors often see mutual funds as their shield against market volatility. The logic is simple: professional managers, diversified portfolios, and the sheer size of mutual funds should protect small investors.
But sometimes, that same size turns into a weapon against them. When large mutual funds—or institutional investors in general—decide to bulk-sell holdings, the aftershocks can devastate prices, wipe out retail wealth, and trap small investors in collapsing positions.
This article examines how bulk selling by big funds works, why it crushes retail investors, and what can be done to protect against it.
What Is Bulk Selling?
Bulk selling occurs when mutual funds or large institutional investors unload massive quantities of shares in a short span.
-
Trigger Events: redemption pressure, portfolio rebalancing, regulatory changes, or panic selling during crises.
-
Scale: A single big AMC may hold 5–10% of a company’s free float. When it sells, the stock doesn’t just move—it collapses.
Why Bulk Selling Hurts Retail Investors
1. Price Crashes from Market Impact
-
Large sell orders swamp the buy side of the market.
-
Prices collapse as liquidity vanishes.
-
Retail investors, often the last to react, sell at rock-bottom prices.
2. NAV Shock for Mutual Fund Investors
-
Bulk selling reduces stock prices across portfolios.
-
Investors in the fund see a sudden fall in NAV, even if they didn’t redeem units.
3. Redemption Domino Effect
-
News of bulk selling triggers panic redemptions from retail investors.
-
Funds sell even more assets to meet redemptions, worsening the fall.
4. Liquidity Traps in Small-Cap Funds
-
In small-cap or mid-cap schemes, a large fund’s exit can wipe out liquidity.
-
Retail investors holding direct stocks or funds are stuck with positions they can’t sell.
How Big Funds Decide to Sell in Bulk
-
Redemption Pressures
During market downturns, retail investors rush to redeem. To meet payouts, AMCs sell large chunks of liquid holdings. -
Regulatory or Risk Mandates
For example, SEBI’s rules on asset allocation or credit downgrades force funds to dump exposures. -
Tactical Portfolio Rebalancing
Fund managers may shift from one sector to another, selling in bulk to free cash. -
Contagion from Defaults
When a corporate defaults (e.g., IL&FS, DHFL), funds with heavy exposure must sell what they can—often their best assets—triggering broader price falls.
Case Studies
1. Franklin Templeton Debt Fund Wind-Up (2020)
-
Franklin shut six debt schemes with ₹26,000 crore in assets.
-
To meet redemptions, the fund started offloading bonds aggressively.
-
Bond prices collapsed, hurting not only Franklin investors but also retail investors holding similar securities elsewhere.
2. Yes Bank Crisis (2020, India)
-
Mutual funds holding Yes Bank’s bonds and equity dumped positions as the bank teetered.
-
Prices collapsed, trapping retail investors who believed Yes Bank was “too big to fail.”
3. Global Example – March 2020 COVID Crash
-
In the US, ETFs and mutual funds dumped equities and bonds to meet outflows.
-
Retail investors who panicked at the same time sold into collapsing markets, locking in heavy losses.
The Asymmetry Between Big Funds and Retail Investors
-
Funds Sell First, Retail Learns Later
AMCs act quickly; retail investors learn only when NAVs drop or disclosures arrive later. -
Market Depth Favors Institutions
Funds use block deals, negotiated trades, or dark pools—options not accessible to retail. -
Retail Buys the Hype, Pays the Crash
Retail often enters stocks after seeing fund houses buy them, only to get trapped when the same funds sell in bulk.
The Regulatory Challenge
SEBI and global regulators face a dilemma:
-
Transparency vs. Market Panic
Real-time disclosure of fund trades could worsen volatility. -
Concentration Rules
Funds are capped on how much they can own of a single stock, but in small-cap segments, even 5% can be destabilizing. -
Liquidity Management Tools
Tools like redemption gates, side pockets, or exit loads exist, but they often kick in after damage is done.
Why Funds Benefit (and Retail Loses)
-
Funds Offload First
Institutions negotiate better prices for block sales, minimizing losses. -
Retail Gets the Slippage
By the time news trickles down, retail investors face collapsed prices. -
NAV Neutrality for AMC Fees
AMCs earn fees on AUM, not performance. Once money is redeemed, they’ve already collected their cut—while retail investors suffer wealth erosion.
How Retail Investors Can Protect Themselves
-
Avoid Herd Mentality
Don’t blindly follow fund buying trends in stocks. Big inflows can reverse quickly. -
Check Liquidity in Portfolios
Look at whether your fund invests in liquid large-caps or illiquid small/mid-caps. Illiquidity magnifies risk during bulk selling. -
Study Concentration
If your fund is heavily exposed to one sector or a few companies, redemption-triggered bulk selling can hurt badly. -
Don’t Panic Redeem
Selling in panic during a bulk-sell wave often locks in maximum losses. Long-term investors should stay invested unless fundamentals are destroyed. -
Diversify Across Fund Categories
Mix equity with debt, large-cap with small-cap, domestic with international funds. Diversification reduces exposure to any one AMC’s bulk-sell shock.
Ethical Dimension
At the heart of bulk selling lies an ethical dilemma:
-
Should AMCs prioritize immediate liquidity for redeeming investors, even if it destroys value for those staying invested?
-
Should they stagger exits to avoid market crashes, risking short-term liquidity crunches?
Currently, AMCs side with the redeeming investor—often at the expense of long-term holders. This asymmetry highlights the structural disadvantage retail investors face.
Conclusion
Bulk selling is the dark side of mutual fund scale. The same size that gives AMCs market power can also crush retail investors when redemptions or rebalancing spark panic sales.
For regulators, the challenge is to strengthen liquidity frameworks and mandate fair disclosure. For AMCs, the responsibility is ethical—to balance short-term redemption demands with long-term portfolio health. And for retail investors, the defense is knowledge: avoid blindly following institutional moves, study liquidity, and diversify.
Because in the battle of scale, when big funds bulk-sell, retail investors are often left holding the bag.
ALSO READ: The “order flow” conspiracy — how brokers really make money
