ETFs and mutual funds are two common ways to invest money. Both allow people to invest in a group of assets, such as company shares, bonds and other securities. This helps reduce risk because your money does not depend on just one company.
Although ETFs and mutual funds have a similar purpose, they work in different ways. They have different costs, rules, prices and methods of purchase. Knowing these differences can help you make a better choice.
What Is an ETF?
ETF stands for Exchange-Traded Fund. It is a fund that holds a group of assets, such as shares or bonds. You can buy and sell ETF units on a stock exchange, just like company shares.
For example, instead of buying shares of 50 companies one by one, you can buy a Nifty 50 ETF. This gives you exposure to the 50 companies that form the Nifty 50 index through a single fund.
Most ETFs follow a market index, but some have active fund managers who choose the assets. ETFs are popular because they often have low costs and allow investors to buy or sell units during market hours.
What Is a Mutual Fund?
A mutual fund collects money from many people and invests it in a mix of assets, such as shares, bonds or other securities. A fund manager or an investment team manages the money based on the fund’s goal.
For example, a Nifty 50 Index Mutual Fund aims to match the performance of the Nifty 50 index. It gives investors access to the same group of major companies without the need to buy each share on their own.
Mutual funds are a common choice for people who want a simple way to invest. They also offer Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs), through which you can invest a fixed amount at regular intervals.
ETF vs Mutual Fund: Key Differences
The main difference between an ETF and a mutual fund is how you buy and sell their units. ETFs trade on stock exchanges, while mutual funds are usually bought or sold through an asset management company (AMC) or an investment platform.
Their prices also work differently. An ETF has a market price that can change throughout the day. A mutual fund uses its Net Asset Value (NAV), which is usually set once each business day.
The minimum amount you need also depends on the fund. For an ETF, you usually need enough money to buy at least one unit. For a mutual fund, the minimum amount depends on the scheme. Some funds allow small SIP amounts.
ETFs are often passive funds that follow a market index, although active ETFs also exist. Mutual funds can be either active or passive. In an active fund, the manager selects assets based on the fund’s goals.
Costs are another key difference. ETFs often have lower expense ratios, but brokerage fees and the gap between buy and sell prices can add to the cost. Mutual funds may have higher expense ratios, especially if a fund has an active manager.
Liquidity also matters. ETF investors depend on buyers and sellers in the stock market. A fund with low trade volume may be harder to sell at a fair price. Mutual fund investors can ask the fund house to redeem their units, subject to the scheme’s rules.
In India, ETFs usually require a Demat and trading account. Most mutual funds do not need a Demat account. SIPs are also widely available for mutual funds, while ETF SIP options depend on the broker or platform.
Advantages and Disadvantages of ETFs
ETFs have several benefits. They often have low expense ratios, offer access to a wide range of assets and allow investors to trade during market hours. Their prices are also easy to check throughout the day.
However, ETFs have a few limits. You usually need a Demat and trading account to buy them. Brokerage fees and bid-ask spreads can add to your costs. Some ETFs have low trade volumes, which can make it harder to buy or sell units at the price you want. Their market price may also be higher or lower than the value of their assets, known as NAV.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Mutual Funds
Mutual funds are simple to use, especially for new investors. They offer SIP options, so you can invest a set amount at regular intervals. You usually do not need a Demat account, and a professional fund manager takes care of the fund’s assets.
However, some mutual funds have higher expense ratios than ETFs. You also cannot buy or sell their units at any time during market hours. The price is based on the applicable NAV. The time taken for a redemption to reach your bank account depends on the scheme.
Which Is Better: ETF or Mutual Fund?
The right choice depends on your needs and comfort with the stock market. Mutual funds may suit beginners and people who want a simple way to invest through monthly SIPs. They are also useful for those who do not have a Demat account.
ETFs may suit investors who want more control over when they buy or sell their units. They can also be a good choice for people who prefer low-cost index funds and have a Demat account.
For long-term investors, both options can offer access to a wide range of assets. The better choice depends on the fund’s cost, performance, risk and purpose.
Example: What Happens If You Invest ₹10,000?
Suppose you have ₹10,000 and want to invest in a fund that follows the Nifty 50 index.
If you choose an ETF, you use your stockbroker to buy units at the market price at that time. The number of units you receive depends on their price and any extra charges.
If you choose a mutual fund, you invest ₹10,000 in a Nifty 50 Index Mutual Fund. The fund house gives you units based on the applicable NAV.
Both funds aim to give you exposure to the same index. However, their costs, purchase methods and tracking results may differ.
Final Verdict
ETFs and mutual funds both offer a simple way to invest in a group of assets. Neither is always better than the other. Your choice should depend on your budget, investment goals and personal needs.
An ETF may suit you if you want the freedom to trade during market hours and prefer a fund with a low expense ratio. A mutual fund may be a better fit if you want easy SIP options, simple access and no need for a Demat account.
Before you invest, check the expense ratio, tracking error, liquidity, tax rules and the fund’s investment goal. Also, remember that all market-based investments carry some risk. Choose a fund that matches your financial goals and your comfort with risk.
ALSO READ: Finance Career Skills That Stay Valuable Over Time
